Ukraine War; Challenges, Deepening Gaps in Intl. Cyberspace Governance

Strategic Council Online - Interview: An expert on international governance of cyberspace, stating that militarization of cyberspace causes a change in understanding from cooperation-oriented cyber geopolitics to conflict-oriented cyber geopolitics, said: Especially after Russia’s attack on Ukraine, the gaps in the discussion of international cyberspace governance have deepened.

Dr. Behzad Ahmadi Lafourki in an interview with the website of the Strategic Council of Foreign Relations, referring to Moscow’s threat that Western cyberattacks against Russia’s infrastructures could lead to a direct military confrontation, stated: The accusations of both sides against each other during this period have been high, but since May 20, that is when Putin warned in the meeting of the Russian Security Council that the infrastructures of foreign countries are being used against the country’s cyberspace and it seems that foreign armies are involved in this respect, the issue of militarization of cyberspace has become more prominent and raised to a higher level.
US preemptive cyberattacks in Ukraine
He said: After Putin’s speech, one of the commanders of the US cyber force in Estonia, which plays an important role in the NATO cyber security arrangements, along with Latvia, said that the US has carried out a range of defensive, offensive and intelligence cyber operations in support of Ukraine. Previously, this command had announced that it was conducting pre-emptive cyber operations in Ukraine.
Ahmadi continued: Those positions of the American side followed the warning of Krutskikh, Putin’s special representative in the field of international cyber security, and he announced that if those attacks continued, there would be a reciprocal response with conventional military action, and the responses may not be limited to cyber reaction. According to Krutskikh, the United States has ignored even its domestic laws in cyberattacks and has obviously lowered the threshold of military use of cyberspace. Although the words of Putin’s representative in showing the conventional military response to cyberattacks are considered as a fundamental development, in fact, here we are more witnessing a preliminary warning from the two sides of Russia and the United States not to raise the threshold of war from a cyber point of view.
He added: Therefore, it can be said that the warnings of both sides are more to create cyber deterrence and the evidence shows that this deterrence has been effective and the range of cyberattacks has not increased as expected. For this reason, except for a few attacks on European satellite companies put at the disposal of the Ukrainian military, the Russians did not expand their cyberattacks outside Ukraine, and no serious cyber actions against European or American companies have been reported.
Turning point of recognition of cyber power of Russians
Ahmadi considered the meeting between Biden and Putin in Geneva last year as a turning point for the Russians and explained: In that meeting, Biden gave the Russians a list of 16 critical American infrastructures and asked for an agreement not to attack them and the Russians were pleased with the recognition of their cyber power. A few months before that, Putin had proposed four points in the field of cyber security to the Americans, which was said to be a very comprehensive and extensive agreement for not attacking each other and to cooperate by opening communication channels and have common protocols.
The expert on international governance of the virtual space called those negotiations effective in controlling the scope of the cyber conflict in the Ukraine war and said: According to what we are witnessing, the cyber conflict can definitely become one of the types of wars in the near future; that is why we are witnessing the formation of cyber command and outer space command in many countries.
Geopoliticization of technology companies
Stating that cyber insecurity can deal a big blow on the economic interests of cyberspace, which has become of great importance to the international economy, Ahmadi noted: In the Ukraine war, technology became geopolitical to a great extent, and this was an important development in the field of ICT. In conflicts, technology companies often try to be neutral so that they can work with both sides of the conflict and benefit; but in that war, they were forced to choose a side, willingly or unwillingly; and of course, it helped to increase their weight, especially Google, Meta and Microsoft companies. Some of them, such as Starlink satellite internet, led by Elon Musk, even voluntarily got involved in that war, which will be instructive to study their behavior.
Emphasizing the role of decentralized technologies in the cyber conflict in the Ukraine war, the expert said: The importance of technologies that are available to individuals and do not require high expertise was shown in that war. At the same time, social networks as well as open source information, such as tracking movements through Google Maps and sharing them, also gained a new role and double importance.
Stabilization of cyber geopolitics, necessity of strengthening Iran’s presence, role in relevant Intl. forums
Ahmadi considered intensification of cyber conflict to the detriment of international economy, causing more serious issues related to the islandization of the Internet and added: Militarization of cyberspace causes a change in understanding from cooperation-oriented cyber geopolitics to conflict-oriented cyber geopolitics. In the Ukraine war, on the one hand, we are witnessing the uncontrolled and irresponsible distribution of cyber weapons and encouraging their use, and on the other hand, intensification of information campaigns to win the war of narratives; in fact, there is a kind of cyber spread on a large scale, which can fuel spread of cybercrimes and attacks in the whole world.
The expert on international governance of virtual cyberspace, referring to the formation of the understanding of the strategic threat of cyberspace from a military point of view in many countries after the war in Ukraine, said: In such an environment, the task of international law that can help reduce conflicts is not clear, and measures in this field in the form of GGE and OEWG have not yet come to fruition, and especially after Russia’s attack on Ukraine, the gaps in the international governance of cyberspace discussion has deepened.
According to Ahmadi, in such an atmosphere, in addition to taking the necessary measures in the field of cyber security and increasing resilience, it is necessary for the country to have a prominent presence in international forums related to the governance of virtual cyberspace and play an effective role in the evolving process of norms, rules and rights shaping such an atmosphere.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST CONTENT

Impact of Operation Cobweb on the Future Course of the Ukraine War

Strategic Council Online – Interview: While Donald Trump, the President of the United States, was pressuring the parties involved in the Ukraine war to initiate negotiations to end the conflict, Operation Cobweb emerged as an unexpected development that transformed the dynamics of this war. This operation, which led to the destruction of several Russian strategic Tu-22M3 bombers, has raised questions about the future of negotiations, the escalation of tensions, and its strategic implications for Russia’s foreign policy and relations with NATO.

Europe’s New Security Strategy Aimed at Defense Self-Sufficiency

Strategic Council Online – Opinion: On June 2, 2025, the Council of the European Union took an unprecedented step toward strengthening Europe’s military self-sufficiency by officially approving a new defense fund worth 150 billion euros. This decision, made after decades of institutional debate and effort in common security policy, is now regarded not merely as a technical or budgetary initiative but as a reflection of a paradigm shift in Europe’s strategic outlook on its security future.

Impact of the U.S.-China Tariff War on Iran’s Economy

Strategic Council Online – Interview: An economist and university faculty member stated that the temporary agreement between the U.S. and China to reduce trade tariffs, recently announced in Geneva, is a turning point in easing trade tensions between the two largest economies in the world. This development, which led to positive reactions in global markets and a rise in economic indicators, has indirect consequences for Iran’s economy.

Reasons for NATO’s Interest in a Military Partnership with Iraq

Strategic Council Online – Interview: A West Asia affairs expert stated that Christoph Henzi, the new NATO commander in Iraq, recently emphasized the North Atlantic Treaty Organization’s (NATO) continued commitment to coordinating and cooperating with Iraqi military and security institutions through experience-sharing, advisory services, and capacity-building.

Prospect of Military Confrontation Between Yemen’s Ansarullah and the Zionist Regime

Strategic Council Online – Interview: A senior West Asia affairs analyst stated that the recent ceasefire agreement between Yemen’s Ansarullah and the U.S., mediated by Oman, led to the cessation of Ansarullah’s attacks on non-Israeli ships in the Red Sea and the suspension of American airstrikes. This agreement, reached after weeks of intense clashes—during which Ansarullah targeted the USS Harry Truman aircraft carrier with missile and drone attacks, inflicting over a billion dollars in losses on the U.S.—marks a turning point in Yemen’s strategic equations. Ansarullah’s military successes, from downing MQ-9 Reaper drones to missile strikes on Ben Gurion Airport, which halted its operations and sent millions of Zionists to shelters, have solidified its position as a key player in the Axis of Resistance.

An Analysis of the Escalating Isolation of Netanyahu Govt Worldwide

Strategic Council Online – Opinion: Netanyahu’s cabinet, which has recently launched a new military operation in Gaza, is insanely massacring civilians. The continuation of the war until the complete destruction of Gaza and its takeover is the ultimate goal of the Zionist regime’s recent military operation.

Reasons for the EU’s Cautious Approach Toward U.S. Tariff Hikes

Online Strategic Council – Interview: A European and American affairs expert stated that the European Union, due to its unstable economic situation and the Ukraine issue, is compelled to accommodate the U.S., and thus, it does not challenge America over the tariff hikes.

Loading

Últimas publicaciones

Impact of Operation Cobweb on the Future Course of the Ukraine War

Strategic Council Online – Interview: While Donald Trump, the President of the United States, was pressuring the parties involved in the Ukraine war to initiate negotiations to end the conflict, Operation Cobweb emerged as an unexpected development that transformed the dynamics of this war. This operation, which led to the destruction of several Russian strategic Tu-22M3 bombers, has raised questions about the future of negotiations, the escalation of tensions, and its strategic implications for Russia’s foreign policy and relations with NATO.

Europe’s New Security Strategy Aimed at Defense Self-Sufficiency

Strategic Council Online – Opinion: On June 2, 2025, the Council of the European Union took an unprecedented step toward strengthening Europe’s military self-sufficiency by officially approving a new defense fund worth 150 billion euros. This decision, made after decades of institutional debate and effort in common security policy, is now regarded not merely as a technical or budgetary initiative but as a reflection of a paradigm shift in Europe’s strategic outlook on its security future.

Impact of the U.S.-China Tariff War on Iran’s Economy

Strategic Council Online – Interview: An economist and university faculty member stated that the temporary agreement between the U.S. and China to reduce trade tariffs, recently announced in Geneva, is a turning point in easing trade tensions between the two largest economies in the world. This development, which led to positive reactions in global markets and a rise in economic indicators, has indirect consequences for Iran’s economy.

Reasons for NATO’s Interest in a Military Partnership with Iraq

Strategic Council Online – Interview: A West Asia affairs expert stated that Christoph Henzi, the new NATO commander in Iraq, recently emphasized the North Atlantic Treaty Organization’s (NATO) continued commitment to coordinating and cooperating with Iraqi military and security institutions through experience-sharing, advisory services, and capacity-building.

Prospect of Military Confrontation Between Yemen’s Ansarullah and the Zionist Regime

Strategic Council Online – Interview: A senior West Asia affairs analyst stated that the recent ceasefire agreement between Yemen’s Ansarullah and the U.S., mediated by Oman, led to the cessation of Ansarullah’s attacks on non-Israeli ships in the Red Sea and the suspension of American airstrikes. This agreement, reached after weeks of intense clashes—during which Ansarullah targeted the USS Harry Truman aircraft carrier with missile and drone attacks, inflicting over a billion dollars in losses on the U.S.—marks a turning point in Yemen’s strategic equations. Ansarullah’s military successes, from downing MQ-9 Reaper drones to missile strikes on Ben Gurion Airport, which halted its operations and sent millions of Zionists to shelters, have solidified its position as a key player in the Axis of Resistance.

An Analysis of the Escalating Isolation of Netanyahu Govt Worldwide

Strategic Council Online – Opinion: Netanyahu’s cabinet, which has recently launched a new military operation in Gaza, is insanely massacring civilians. The continuation of the war until the complete destruction of Gaza and its takeover is the ultimate goal of the Zionist regime’s recent military operation.

Reasons for the EU’s Cautious Approach Toward U.S. Tariff Hikes

Online Strategic Council – Interview: A European and American affairs expert stated that the European Union, due to its unstable economic situation and the Ukraine issue, is compelled to accommodate the U.S., and thus, it does not challenge America over the tariff hikes.

Loading
Samir Design Group گروه طراحی سمیر