Taliban Retreat and Ambiguities in Possible Peace with America

2020/02/26 | Note, political, top news

Strategic Council Online: Donald Trump is now in dire need of foreign accomplishments in 2020, the year of presidential elections, and if Washington can reach a deal with the Taliban and sign it, Trump could use it as bargaining chip. Pir Mohammad Molazehi - Afghanistan Affairs Expert

Taliban announced that the group’s talks with the United States are over and that the document on the peace agreement and its annexes will be finalized and signed (by the end of February). Sheila Shahin, a spokesman for the Taliban’s political bureau in Qatar, said the two sides were to issue separate statements, including a date for signing the agreement.

It seems that after 11 rounds of talks between Zalmay Khalilzad, the US special envoy for peace and the Taliban, Khalilzad has succeeded in convincing the Taliban that they cannot revive their Islamic Emirate as long as the Americans are in the country. But they have the chance to come to power by political means, accepting democratic mechanisms and by-elections (if they win). It seems that part of the Taliban, including the Quetta Council, have accepted this line of thought, and that Quetta Council has now reached an agreement with the United States.

So it can be said that an agreement in principle has been reached between the Taliban and the US, although in the last minute there may be a problem and disrupt everything but the reality is that a peace agreement is likely to be signed.

Regarding US goals of pursuing peace talks, Donald Trump from the very beginning that he entered the election campaign one of the issues he raised was why America is sustaining human and financial losses in Afghanistan and Iraq. Trump had said in his publicity slogans that if he enters the White House he would prepare the ground for the departure of Iraq and Afghanistan.

With such a track record, Donald Trump now desperately needs an outsider in the presidential election year, and if Washington can come to terms with the Taliban and signs the peace deal, Trump could use it as a bargaining chip in the upcoming presidential vote.

The Taliban, on the other hand, seek power, while they have two characteristics: First it is ethnically monopolistic and second it is ideologically monopolistic. These two traits put the Taliban in a difficult position in reaching an understanding without achieving their goals.

One of the goals the Taliban are seeking is the complete withdrawal of US and NATO troops from Afghanistan, but they appear to have shown some flexibility in this regard. So the United States is withdrawing most of its troops from Afghanistan for the purpose of election campaign publicity but it is likely that some of the US troops will remain at their bases and the Taliban have no choice but to accept it.

Another thing that remains unclear is what would be the fate of the current Kabul government? Taliban do not recognize the ruling establishment and believe it is a subservient government.

Now elections have been held in Afghanistan that depend on the outcome of the peace talks between the Taliban and the United States. That is why they have been counting the votes for several months now and disagreements are high between negotiating parties.

In this regard, General Dostum recently announced that if the election results were announced in favour of Ashraf Ghani and the Northern alliance’s line of thinking was not operationalized, they would form a parallel government in the North. This means the outbreak of civil war in Afghanistan is possible.

Given all these circumstances, the United States may implement the previous plan for the interim government to work for 18 months to reform the constitution, in which case the Taliban must also be given a share in power and assume legal status. The power structure also needs to be changed.

So at this stage, it can be imagined that an agreement between the Taliban and the United States would be operational, but behind the scenes, they might have reached a point that has not yet been announced, so it is not yet possible to say whether the Taliban have accepted for part of the US forces remain in Afghanistan or not? Or whether the Taliban accepted that the rest of the ethnic groups have a share in power? Of course, despite the uncertainties, the deal looks to be close and likely to be signed soon.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LATEST CONTENT

SCFR’s Statement Regarding the Gaza Ceasefire

Strategic Council Online: The Strategic Council on Foreign Relations (SCFR), in a statement, congratulated the heroic Palestinian nation, the members of the Axis of Resistance, and all freedom-loving people across the world on the occasion of the Gaza ceasefire. Addressing the Palestinians, SCFR stated: “You have once again proven that the will of nations cannot be suppressed by military force.”

Consequences of Recent Military Border Tension between Pakistan and Afghanistan

Strategic Council Online—Opinion: The recent military border tensions between Pakistan and Afghanistan have characteristics that completely distinguish them from the process of increasing and gradual conflict between the two countries over the past three and a half years and even before that. Their consequences make it necessary for the neighboring countries to consult.

US Objectives and Strategy for Revival of ISIS in the Region

Strategic Council Online – Opinion: With the dominance of armed groups in Syria and the possible intensification of political, military, and security chaos in the country on the one hand and widespread foreign interventions on the other, the risk of ISIS revival has become stronger not only in Syria but also in the country’s surroundings, including Iraq.

Analysis of Saudi Arabia’s Approach to the Syrian Interim Government

Strategic Council Online – Interview: An expert on regional issues assessed the visit of the Syrian Interim Government’s Foreign Minister to Saudi Arabia as a progressive and important step, saying: Contrary to some news and analysis about Saudi Arabia’s agreement and support for the new developments in Syria and the formation of an interim government by Syrian opposition forces, the Riyadh government has serious concerns and worries about the future of this government.

US National Strategy to Counter Islamophobia and Its Contradictory Practices

Strategic Council Online – Opinion: The US National Strategy to Counter Islamophobia, apparently to justify and explain policies to defend the rights of racial minorities, especially Muslims living in the United States, was unveiled by the White House on December 12, 2024, in a situation where world public opinion has been witnessing with astonishment for more than a year the unprecedented increase in the shipment of deadly weapons and the full-scale political, legal, international and media support of the United States for the genocide and the commission of heinous crimes by the occupying and child-killing Israeli regime in the Gaza Strip, the West Bank and other parts of the occupied territories against Palestinians, mainly civilians, women, children, the elderly, journalists, hospitals and all vital centers and infrastructures of the residents of the occupied territories.

Analysis of the Causes and Consequences of Germany’s Support for the Zionist Regime in the Gaza War

Strategic Council Online – Opinion: After the end of World War II, Germany was among the European governments that did the most “good service” to the Zionist regime; the reason for this is quite clear. Germany considers itself “indebted” to the Zionist regime because of Hitler’s behavior and actions towards the Jews. Therefore, in order to compensate for Hitler’s actions and “gain the trust” of the Zionists and at the same time “benefit from the Jewish lobby,” it did not neglect any service to Tel Aviv.

Trump’s Return to the White House and Scenarios for Ukrainian War

Strategic Council Online – Opinion: Trump’s return to the White House has confronted Ukraine and its European supporters with important questions: Will the United States continue to provide weapons and financial support to Kiev, or, as Trump claims, will peace prevail in Ukraine-Russia relations? If an agreement is reached to end the war, what will be the fate of Ukraine’s lost territories? Will peace be a lasting agreement, or will it pave the way for another major conflict? These questions have not yet received a clear answer.

Loading

Últimas publicaciones

SCFR’s Statement Regarding the Gaza Ceasefire

Strategic Council Online: The Strategic Council on Foreign Relations (SCFR), in a statement, congratulated the heroic Palestinian nation, the members of the Axis of Resistance, and all freedom-loving people across the world on the occasion of the Gaza ceasefire. Addressing the Palestinians, SCFR stated: “You have once again proven that the will of nations cannot be suppressed by military force.”

Consequences of Recent Military Border Tension between Pakistan and Afghanistan

Strategic Council Online—Opinion: The recent military border tensions between Pakistan and Afghanistan have characteristics that completely distinguish them from the process of increasing and gradual conflict between the two countries over the past three and a half years and even before that. Their consequences make it necessary for the neighboring countries to consult.

US Objectives and Strategy for Revival of ISIS in the Region

Strategic Council Online – Opinion: With the dominance of armed groups in Syria and the possible intensification of political, military, and security chaos in the country on the one hand and widespread foreign interventions on the other, the risk of ISIS revival has become stronger not only in Syria but also in the country’s surroundings, including Iraq.

Analysis of Saudi Arabia’s Approach to the Syrian Interim Government

Strategic Council Online – Interview: An expert on regional issues assessed the visit of the Syrian Interim Government’s Foreign Minister to Saudi Arabia as a progressive and important step, saying: Contrary to some news and analysis about Saudi Arabia’s agreement and support for the new developments in Syria and the formation of an interim government by Syrian opposition forces, the Riyadh government has serious concerns and worries about the future of this government.

US National Strategy to Counter Islamophobia and Its Contradictory Practices

Strategic Council Online – Opinion: The US National Strategy to Counter Islamophobia, apparently to justify and explain policies to defend the rights of racial minorities, especially Muslims living in the United States, was unveiled by the White House on December 12, 2024, in a situation where world public opinion has been witnessing with astonishment for more than a year the unprecedented increase in the shipment of deadly weapons and the full-scale political, legal, international and media support of the United States for the genocide and the commission of heinous crimes by the occupying and child-killing Israeli regime in the Gaza Strip, the West Bank and other parts of the occupied territories against Palestinians, mainly civilians, women, children, the elderly, journalists, hospitals and all vital centers and infrastructures of the residents of the occupied territories.

Analysis of the Causes and Consequences of Germany’s Support for the Zionist Regime in the Gaza War

Strategic Council Online – Opinion: After the end of World War II, Germany was among the European governments that did the most “good service” to the Zionist regime; the reason for this is quite clear. Germany considers itself “indebted” to the Zionist regime because of Hitler’s behavior and actions towards the Jews. Therefore, in order to compensate for Hitler’s actions and “gain the trust” of the Zionists and at the same time “benefit from the Jewish lobby,” it did not neglect any service to Tel Aviv.

Trump’s Return to the White House and Scenarios for Ukrainian War

Strategic Council Online – Opinion: Trump’s return to the White House has confronted Ukraine and its European supporters with important questions: Will the United States continue to provide weapons and financial support to Kiev, or, as Trump claims, will peace prevail in Ukraine-Russia relations? If an agreement is reached to end the war, what will be the fate of Ukraine’s lost territories? Will peace be a lasting agreement, or will it pave the way for another major conflict? These questions have not yet received a clear answer.

Loading
Samir Design Group گروه طراحی سمیر